The Postmistress Cafe and Store

37 Old Great Western Hwy, Hartley NSW 2790, Australia
$$$ Cafe
(57 Reviews)
Price Range $1–20

Discover a hidden gem along the Old Great Western Highway — The Postmistress Cafe and Store. Nestled in the picturesque Hartley, NSW, this delightful establishment is more than just a cafe; it’s an inviting space where community meets quality, offering an array of scrumptious treats and a warm ambiance.

Walking into The Postmistress is like stepping into a cozy nook that feels both rustic and welcoming. With ample indoor seating by the crackling fire and a charming outdoor balcony bathed in sunlight, it's the perfect spot to unwind, any time of the year. The cafe features a laid-back atmosphere that encourages patrons to linger a little longer, meeting friends or simply enjoying a quiet moment with a book.

Menu Highlights: The Postmistress Cafe has a curated menu that focuses on quality over quantity. Customers rave about the signature toasties, with the ham variant receiving particular praise for its savory, comforting flavors. Other popular offerings include delicious homemade cakes that perfectly complement the expertly brewed coffee. Don’t miss the extraordinary coffee that patrons repeatedly mention — it's a robust brew that pairs beautifully with a slice of lemon cake or the irresistible burnt butter and cinnamon choc chip cookie.

Beyond the food, The Postmistress Cafe emphasizes providing a delightful customer experience. Guests have noted the friendly and attentive staff, creating a warmth that enhances the overall visit. As one satisfied customer, Jacob Heal, mentioned, the atmosphere is so enjoyable that it beckons you to return, time and again.

For those traveling with furry friends, this cafe doesn’t overlook their needs either; they even offer dog treats, ensuring that everyone in the family feels welcome. The ample parking, including space for caravans, makes this a convenient stop for travelers journeying between Mudgee and Sydney or on their way heading towards Dubbo.

What truly sets The Postmistress Cafe apart is the genuine connection it fosters with its patrons. Reviews reflect love not just for the food, but for the experience as a whole — Sue Dillon shared that the atmosphere is enhanced by friendly staff who contribute to an inviting vibe. Whether you're indulging in a rich hot chocolate on a chilly day or savoring a golden sausage roll with homemade tomato sauce, every bite and sip is designed to make you feel at home.

If you're looking for a café that offers delicious food, great coffee, and a delightful setting, The Postmistress Cafe and Store should be at the top of your list. Whether you're stopping by for a quick break or a leisurely meal, the enchanting experience is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Service options
Outdoor seating
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great coffee
Great dessert
Popular for
Lunch
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dessert
Seating
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Pets
Dogs allowed
Dogs allowed outside
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

Closed

Wednesday

Closed

Thursday

10:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Friday

10:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Saturday

09:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Sunday

09:00 AM - 03:00 PM

57 Reviews
Sammi Jaeger

10 Oct 2025

We stopped in for coffee, toastie and treats on a road trip between Mudgee & Sydney. A really cute spot with beautiful produce. We sat on the balcony in the sun. Lots of outdoor seating available as well as indoor by the fire. We had the signature toastie + ham which was delicious. As well as coffees, a slice of lemon cake and a burnt butter and cinnamon choc chip cookie. Everything was tasty and appropriately priced. Only issue was our coffees came out long after we had finished our food. Would stop in again.

Jenny Seabrook

26 Sep 2025

Beautiful rustic cafe with great coffee and homemade cakes. We stopped here passing through and were very glad we did. There are so many yummy things to choose from. Also, clean toilets nearby. Highly recommended. We will be back. Sit inside or outside. They even have dog treats. There is plenty of parking with space for a caravan to park and turn around.

Sue Dillon

08 Sep 2025

Place is easy to find, lots of parking. Has a limited but quality menu, lots of fresh desserts and pastries. Outside and inside seating. Very friendly staff a nice atmosphere. The food was quick and fresh, we got Scones, hot chocolates and sausage roll. All of the food was delicious. Would highly recommend

Lucas YOUNG

05 Aug 2025

You must stop here. Incredible little cafe, staff are super friendly, coffee is brilliant, sausage roll is out of this world! They have other food and cakes too but that’s what i tried and it was amazing!!!

Jacob Heal

03 Aug 2025

Love their beef sausage roll that goes with homemade tomato sauce. Very nice stopping point on way to Dubbo or Mudgee ! Waitress lady is so friendly and she taught my child to say Enjoy! Atmosphere is warm friendly and make people wanting to go back many many times!

Kimberly Matthews

09 Jul 2025

We had a fabulous lunch here on the way home from Sydney a couple of weeks ago! It's such a lovely location to sit and look out at the view, with comfortable outdoor shaded tables. And the staff were amazing at helping to create a meal I could eat using their existing menu and ingredients! All our meals were delicious and fresh, with the best cooked quinoa I've ever eaten!

Ante Bruning

05 Jul 2025

One of the best cafe meals I’ve had in a very long time - a delicious treat after a camping weekend at Lake Lyell. Coffee was divine, scones were soft and fluffy, the beetroot and goats cheese tart was titillating, the carrot and coconut cake was heaven, the Moroccan orange almond cake was moist and mouthwatering. The kids enjoyed their egg and bacon roll, and toastie - little one said he liked his roll “more than sushi,” which is a huge claim. 10s, 10s, 10s across the board.

joshlawson1089

16 Jun 2025

What a delightful stop on the highway! The atmosphere sitting in the garden is lovely to look at all the trees surrounding, I went in the autumn time so it was especially pretty. The coffee was amazing but the toasty Wow, I’ve never had better. I had a refreshing homemade lemonade to finish, it was just a little tart and perfect to end the meal. Pop in and see the store off to the side, there are some nice products to browse through.

Join the The Postmistress Cafe and Store Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.